Keywords:
procedure . credit counselling . dismissal .

  • 6 Cases on This Topic
  • Cases for Zip
  • All Cases By Date
  • Cases A - Z

Cases for Zip , California Northern District Bankruptcy Court

Ninth Circuit Cases

• In re Otero

Bankr. N.D.Cal. - No. 09-71420-TG - 2010-02-12 - 13 ,

Google ID#: 10452106880440642720
(Type E : )

The court said, "there are three prongs that a debtor must satisfy to obtain a temporary waiver of the pre-petition credit counseling requirement. The Court agrees with the debtor that the imminent forclosure of one's home satisfies the first prong of Section 109(h)(3). However, the debtor is unable to satisfy the second prong" [i.e. that debtor sought credit counseling at least five days prior to filing and was unable to obtain an appointment]. Because of this, the court dismissed debtor's case.

Other Circuits

• In re Alexander

Bankr. N.D.N.Y. - 432 B.R. 41 - 2010-03-05 - ,

Google ID#: 15786977107430849903
(Type E : )

Debtor in prison was denied waiver or exemption from required pre-petition credit counseling. Court held that section 109(h) is to be narrowly construed to include only incapacity, disability, or active military duty.

The section reads: "an individual may not be a debtor under this title unless such individual has, during the 180-day period preceding the date of filing of the petition by such individual, received from an approved nonprofit budget and credit counseling agency described in section 111(a) an individual or group briefing (including a briefing conducted by telephone or on the Internet) that outlined the opportunities for available credit counseling and assisted such individual in performing a related budget analysis."

• In re Capos-Luna

Bankr.E.D.Virgina - No. 09-15696-SSM - 2009-12-16 - both , na

Google ID#: 7653436524743627402
(Type A : Case must be dismissed where no certificate of credit counseling completion )

Attorney must disgorge $2,000 fee paid by debtor where case had to be dismissed because debtor had not completed credit counseling, requiring the court to dismiss the case. Although the forms said counseling had been completed, there was no certificate of completion. Counsel was lax in failing to confirm that debtor had, indeed, attended credit counseling and got the certificate.

• In re Crawford

Bankr.D.New Mexico - No. 09-14645-j7 - 2009-12-14 - both , na

Google ID#: 184027940767717737
(Type B : Case must be dismissed where credit counseling was completed MORE than 180 days prior to filing )

Debtor's attorney screwed up by computing 180 day credit counseling period to be "six months" rather than 180 days. Debtor had completed counseling 181 days before filing, and then did a makeup 4 days after filing. Court said that it had no choice but to dismiss the case.

• In re Crawford

Bankr. D.N.M. - 430 B.R. 833 - 2009-12-14 - 7 ,

Google ID#: 12540772773578594918
(Type A : Case must be dismissed where no certificate of credit counseling completion )

The debtors obtained credit counseling 181 days before filing for bankruptcy, and the court ruled it had no discretion but to dismiss the case unless debtors obtained counseling within 180 days of filing.

• In re Wise

Bankr.N.D.Alabama - 415 B.R. 579 - 2009-09-02 - 13 ,

Google ID#: 16147524897956497060
(Type D : Can credit counseling be completed on day of filing, or must it be completed the day before filing )

Although debtor must seek credit counseling at least one day BEFORE filing, failure of creditor to raise objection until plan confirmation means objection has been waived.

• In re Alexander

Bankr. N.D.N.Y. - 432 B.R. 41 - 2010-03-05 - ,

Google ID#: 15786977107430849903
(Type E : )

Debtor in prison was denied waiver or exemption from required pre-petition credit counseling. Court held that section 109(h) is to be narrowly construed to include only incapacity, disability, or active military duty.

The section reads: "an individual may not be a debtor under this title unless such individual has, during the 180-day period preceding the date of filing of the petition by such individual, received from an approved nonprofit budget and credit counseling agency described in section 111(a) an individual or group briefing (including a briefing conducted by telephone or on the Internet) that outlined the opportunities for available credit counseling and assisted such individual in performing a related budget analysis."

• In re Otero

Bankr. N.D.Cal. - No. 09-71420-TG - 2010-02-12 - 13 ,

Google ID#: 10452106880440642720
(Type E : )

The court said, "there are three prongs that a debtor must satisfy to obtain a temporary waiver of the pre-petition credit counseling requirement. The Court agrees with the debtor that the imminent forclosure of one's home satisfies the first prong of Section 109(h)(3). However, the debtor is unable to satisfy the second prong" [i.e. that debtor sought credit counseling at least five days prior to filing and was unable to obtain an appointment]. Because of this, the court dismissed debtor's case.

• In re Capos-Luna

Bankr.E.D.Virgina - No. 09-15696-SSM - 2009-12-16 - both , na

Google ID#: 7653436524743627402
(Type A : Case must be dismissed where no certificate of credit counseling completion )

Attorney must disgorge $2,000 fee paid by debtor where case had to be dismissed because debtor had not completed credit counseling, requiring the court to dismiss the case. Although the forms said counseling had been completed, there was no certificate of completion. Counsel was lax in failing to confirm that debtor had, indeed, attended credit counseling and got the certificate.

• In re Crawford

Bankr.D.New Mexico - No. 09-14645-j7 - 2009-12-14 - both , na

Google ID#: 184027940767717737
(Type B : Case must be dismissed where credit counseling was completed MORE than 180 days prior to filing )

Debtor's attorney screwed up by computing 180 day credit counseling period to be "six months" rather than 180 days. Debtor had completed counseling 181 days before filing, and then did a makeup 4 days after filing. Court said that it had no choice but to dismiss the case.

• In re Crawford

Bankr. D.N.M. - 430 B.R. 833 - 2009-12-14 - 7 ,

Google ID#: 12540772773578594918
(Type A : Case must be dismissed where no certificate of credit counseling completion )

The debtors obtained credit counseling 181 days before filing for bankruptcy, and the court ruled it had no discretion but to dismiss the case unless debtors obtained counseling within 180 days of filing.

• In re Wise

Bankr.N.D.Alabama - 415 B.R. 579 - 2009-09-02 - 13 ,

Google ID#: 16147524897956497060
(Type D : Can credit counseling be completed on day of filing, or must it be completed the day before filing )

Although debtor must seek credit counseling at least one day BEFORE filing, failure of creditor to raise objection until plan confirmation means objection has been waived.

All Cases A to Z

  • In re Alexander, 432 B.R. 41 , (Bankr. N.D.N.Y. ) 2010-03-05, #15786977107430849903
  • In re Capos-Luna, No. 09-15696-SSM , (Bankr.E.D.Virgina ) 2009-12-16, #7653436524743627402
  • In re Crawford, No. 09-14645-j7 , (Bankr.D.New Mexico ) 2009-12-14, #184027940767717737
  • In re Crawford, 430 B.R. 833 , (Bankr. D.N.M. ) 2009-12-14, #12540772773578594918
  • In re Otero, No. 09-71420-TG , (Bankr. N.D.Cal. ) 2010-02-12, #10452106880440642720
  • In re Wise, 415 B.R. 579 , (Bankr.N.D.Alabama ) 2009-09-02, #16147524897956497060